← Fund selection & CIO-office support

Pension funds / Manager selection & due diligence

Which manager fits?
Show the reasons.

WSP compares candidates, tests the evidence and recommends a shortlist. Your pension fund pays WSP and makes the appointment.

Discuss your selection mandate

Scope, deliverables and fee agreed before work starts.

WSP / Working exampleIllustrative only

Three proposals. One reasoned shortlist.

Manager A / broad fitTeam succession question remains
RESERVE
Manager B / strongest fitVerify reporting and transition plan
PREFERRED
Manager C / mandate mismatchProposed discretion exceeds the brief
DO NOT ADVANCE
WSP: advance Manager B, subject to checks.Pension fund commissions and pays WSP. Committee appoints.

Illustrative example · no client information or investment recommendation.

A defined client assignment

What you receive.

01

Comparable proposals

An agreed mandate brief, candidate requests and a comparison on common criteria.

02

A reasoned WSP view

A preferred candidate or shortlist, reasons, evidence gaps and conditions.

03

A decision record + readout

A committee presentation, diligence findings and the next actions before appointment.

See the fictional worked example ↓

Pension fund / Fictional selection dossier

Compare the evidence.
Make the appointment.

Fictional candidates and findings. A sample shortlist, not a completed appointment recommendation.

The agreed brief

A global equity mandate.

CHF reporting · defined benchmark · agreed risk limits · transparent holdings · documented transition

CLIENT: THE PENSION FUND
WSP recommendation

Advance Manager B. Keep A in reserve.

B best matches the brief. Validate reporting and transition before appointment. Keep A in reserve; C requests discretion outside the mandate.

MANAGER A

Credible alternative.

RESERVE
Mandate fit
Matches the agreed investment scope.
Team
Lead-manager succession not documented.
Reporting
Sample supplied; required fields present.
Transition
Outline supplied; detailed costs outstanding.
WSP judgement and next question

Retain as an alternative. Request named responsibilities and a succession plan, then examine continuity of the investment process. An unanswered succession question is not evidence that a departure is imminent.

MANAGER B

Strongest fit.

PREFERRED / CONDITIONAL
Mandate fit
Matches the brief; limits mapped explicitly.
Team
Decision roles and deputies documented.
Reporting
Capabilities described; sample to validate.
Transition
Implementation sequence supplied; sign-off pending.
Why WSP prefers B

B provides the clearest account of how the mandate would be managed and controlled. That supports progression, not unconditional approval. Validate a reporting sample against the pension fund’s requirements and agree the transition responsibilities before recommending appointment.

MANAGER C

Wrong brief.

DO NOT ADVANCE
Mandate fit
Requests discretion outside agreed limits.
Team
Responsibilities documented.
Reporting
Standard package supplied.
Transition
Not examined after scope mismatch.
Why WSP stops here

Do not advance under the current brief. A credible team does not resolve a mandate mismatch. If the pension fund changes its requirements, reassess eligible proposals on the same revised basis. Unexamined transition work is not a negative diligence finding.

Conditions before appointment.

01WSP + Manager B / validateCheck a sample report against required exposures, limits and reporting frequency.
02WSP + pension fund / complete the caseCompare total fees and transition costs on the same assumptions; close the remaining due-diligence questions.
03Pension fund / decideReview WSP’s final recommendation, approve the manager and terms through the authorised body, and record the reasons.
What supports the comparison?

A commissioned dossier identifies the agreed criteria, dated submissions, interviews, source documents, follow-up answers and unresolved items. This sample compares mandate fit, team continuity, reporting and transition only. Fees, performance analysis, operational controls, legal terms and reference checks are not evidenced here. The example supports a preferred finalist, not a completed appointment recommendation. No invented score or performance ranking is presented.

Who pays / Who decides

The pension fund pays.
Its authorised body decides.

Pension fundAgrees scope and fee
WSPRuns selection and provides advice
Authorised committee or boardMakes the appointment

No participation or selection fees from candidates. Relationships and conflicts are disclosed and assessed before acceptance; the institution retains appointment authority.

Work with WSP

Bring the decision.
Agree the work.

Brief → Scope, fee and timing → WSP view + discussion

What to send us

Start with the asset class, mandate objectives, approximate mandate size, constraints and decision timetable. Include the investment regulations and existing mandate brief where relevant. WSP agrees the information needed and secure exchange arrangements.

Who pays and how is the fee set?

The pension fund or commissioning institution pays WSP. Scope, deliverables, fee and timing are agreed before candidate outreach. No candidate fees for participation or selection. Relevant relationships and conflicts are disclosed and assessed before acceptance.

Selection, due diligence or an existing-manager review?

Commission the selection process, a defined diligence review of finalists, or a review of an existing mandate. Agree the investment and operational examination, manager access, evidence requirements and committee output. Continuing monitoring is a separate scope.

WSP organises the agreed selection and provides research and advice. The pension fund retains governance responsibilities and appointment authority. This fictional sample is not a certification or a completed assessment of real managers.

Talk to WSP

Which mandate is coming before your committee?

Discuss your selection mandate